An entertaining movie. I enjoyed it, but I think I’m a bit soft on it. It felt like a movie that was trying very hard to find itself, but just didn’t quite make it.
Peter Parker is Spider-Man (spoiler), and everyone knew it. But at the end of No Way Home, the mystical magical arts of Dr. Strange erased everyone’s memory of Peter Parker.
So, Spider-Man has been living like this for presumably about four years. In early scenes, you see him take down Scorpion (who returns) and Tombstone (who does not). Figuring out the villain aspect, I don’t know, felt less fleshed out. There was a “villain” they wanted to introduce, and it all felt like setup. Then, in real time, we see Frank Castle as Punisher, played by the delightful Jon Bernthal.
It starts off as a detective story, with Holland’s Parker mourning his love, MJ, who no longer remembers him. Then shifts to an extortion plot, where this newly revealed villain gets Parker to help by threatening MJ. Then a siege movie, with a cameo by the Hulk — which felt unnecessary. And finally, a revenge story on the road to redemption.
Look, fine — a movie can be a lot of things. But I don’t think this one navigates the tonal shifts all that effectively.
Do we want Peter to get back with MJ? Maybe. Someone suggested that removing MJ entirely makes it more compelling, and I might agree. But I really like Ned, and maybe it’s good to keep him in there.
Then there was the whole Jean Grey problem, which — huge spoiler — but I feel like I haven’t heard much about that in the interim since the film’s release, and subsequent billion dollar box office. But I digress. Look, the first two-thirds of the movie, JG is a bad guy? Killing, no problem. Attacking and mind-shifting across New York? Whatever. Then, once you find out why she’s bad, she’s suddenly not so bad? No, it didn’t work.
Not for me.
Florence Pugh was a highlight, and I would watch her in anything she does. I’m a fan of the trio as well — Holland, Zendaya, and Jacob Batalon (who plays Ned). I think there were some great moments in this. Some chances taken, and a lot of good filmmaking. But I think it lacks the fun of the previous three Spider-Man movies, which, to me, is Holland’s strongest appeal as the character.